The recruitment trust gap: why candidates are walking away and how to fix it

Trust isn’t just about whether a candidate believes an employer is a good place to work. It’s built throughout the recruitment journey, from the first application to the period between accepting an offer and starting a new role.


Yet unanswered applications, lengthy hiring processes and uncertainty around job offers can quickly undermine that trust. CV-Library’s Candidate Behaviour Barometer 2026, which surveyed 1,043 UK jobseekers and 233 recruiters and employers, highlights a growing disconnect between what candidates expect and what recruiters are delivering.

Communication is where trust starts to break down

For candidates, a lack of communication remains a major frustration when looking for work. More than two-thirds (68%) say they’ve been ghosted by an employer after submitting an application, rising to 46% among those ghosted after an interview.

Recruiters recognise there is room for improvement. More than four in 10 recruiters (44%) say candidates occasionally or frequently drop out of their recruitment process because of delays or poor communication.

This is particularly important given that 92% consider speed between interview and offer either critical or important. Yet, despite recognising the importance of moving quickly, only a third (33%) typically complete their hiring process within two weeks.

An accepted offer doesn’t guarantee a secure hire

Trust also matters beyond the point of an offer. More than half (52%) of candidates say they would accept a job offer while continuing to look for other opportunities. Among these, 47% say they don’t fully trust an offer until they’ve signed a contract and started.

Recruiters are seeing the consequences first-hand. Seven in 10 have experienced candidates accepting an offer before withdrawing, with 15% saying this is happening more frequently.

While recruiters most commonly attribute withdrawals to better salaries elsewhere (65%) and counter-offers (55%), a lack of confidence in the opportunity can also make it harder to secure a candidate’s commitment.

The period between accepting an offer and starting a new role can leave candidates feeling vulnerable to second thoughts. Maintaining regular contact, providing clear updates, and reinforcing expectations can help keep them engaged and reduce the risk of losing a hire at the final hurdle.

The commercial cost of losing candidate trust

For recruitment businesses, these problems extend beyond a frustrating candidate experience.

Among recruitment consultancies, 65% say late-stage candidate withdrawals delay the filling of client vacancies, while 64% report losing revenue or placement fees as a result. More than half (52%) also say these withdrawals damage client relationships.

Losing a candidate late in the process can mean repeating weeks of work, disappointing clients, and potentially missing revenue. Candidate engagement should be a commercial priority, not simply a tick-boxing exercise.

Building trust throughout the recruitment journey

Improving the experience doesn’t necessarily require a complete overhaul of existing processes. Small changes can make a significant difference:

  • keeping candidates informed even when there is no immediate update,
  • setting realistic expectations around timescales,
  • providing honest feedback,
  • and maintaining contact between an offer acceptance and the start date.

Recruiters should also consider whether their processes are as straightforward from the candidate’s perspective as they appear internally.

Ultimately, securing a candidate should not be treated as the finish line. Building trust and maintaining relationships at every stage of the hiring journey can help recruiters protect future hires, strengthen client relationships, and create a better experience for everyone.

From candidate records to live candidate intelligence

An ATS will continue to play an important role in recruitment, but it does not always provide the most up to date picture of what is happening in the candidate market.

That is where WorkTool can sit alongside a construction recruitment agency’s existing systems and recruitment channels.

Construction workers using WorkTool keep their own information up to date through the app, including their trade, location, CSCS card and qualifications, transport and current availability. Agencies can then search the WorkTool candidate community using that information to identify relevant workers more quickly.

This gives agencies access to a more live layer of candidate intelligence, helping recruiters get closer to answering the question that matters when a client requirement arrives:

Who is suitable, and who is actually available for work right now?

Partner Spotlight: CV-Library

Building trust throughout the recruitment journey starts with connecting candidates to the right opportunities and making the hiring process as straightforward as possible.

CV-Library helps recruitment agencies find relevant talent quickly, with more than 22 million CVs in its database and 360,000 new or updated CVs added every month.

Established in 2000, CV-Library works with tens of thousands of recruitment agencies and employers, helping them source candidates and reach more jobseekers. Its multi-award-winning platform also attracts more than 20 million unique visitors every quarter, generating millions of job applications. Whether you’re looking to proactively source candidates through CV Search or advertise vacancies across a network of more than 300 job sites, CV-Library offers flexible recruitment solutions to help you reach the right people, fill vacancies and keep your hiring moving.

Take the next step

Building trust starts with connecting the right people with the right opportunities. Explore how CV-Library can support your recruitment goals with a free trial.

QUBA CTA

Let’s chat about
your business needs

Get in touch and find out how we can take your recruitment business to the next level. You can book an appointment or simply give our team a call on 0333 049 1099

Let's talk funding